The Catholic Church is supposed to proclaim the truth, not reflect the culture.
So IT DOES NOT MATTER if every single Catholic woman in America uses artificial birth control. (They don’t, by the way. And that 98% figure that the media is flinging around is . . . shall we say . . . imprecise. I’ll write about that another time.)
I’d say 98% of us Catholics have been unkind, have been dishonest, have yelled at our kids, have in general failed to live good Christian lives, some more than others. Because, you know, we are human. Does that mean the Church is supposed to fold and say those things aren’t sinful anymore?
This debate is not about reproductive freedom (that’s the liberal spin). It’s not about the fact that most Catholics dissent from the Church’s teachings (that’s the media spin). It’s not even really about President Obama being in a war against religion (that’s the conservative spin). No, what this is about is freedom of religion. It’s about the Constitution. Is about the dismantling of a right that is absolutely intrinsic to what it means to be an American. That’s why many progressive Catholics, erstwhile supporters of the President and his health care plan, are outraged. This is so foundational that the lack of uproar among the Catholics in the pews–indeed, among people in general–astonishes me.
Don’t people remember their American history classes from grade school? You know, the ones in which we all learned about people coming to this country to be free to practice their religion without government interference? What if President Obama wanted to mandate (as has happened in France) that Muslim girls stop wearing their headscarves in public schools. I don’t wear a headscarf. The practice does not make any sense to me personally. Some argue that it is demeaning to women. But I would be furious if anyone tried to legislate against it and I bet a lot of others would as well.
Is it a problem that this disconnect between Church teaching on artificial contraception and the practice of most Catholics exists? You bet it is. There’s blame enough to go around, and I’ll write about that elsewhere so as not to cloud the issue.
American freedoms have already been eroded in the name of the “War on Terrorism.” Do liberals really want to join in stripping away more of the rights on which this country was built?